Older woman comparing hearing aid options at home

Over-the-Counter vs. Prescription Hearing Aids: How to Choose

Choosing a hearing aid can feel overwhelming. There are different styles, features, prices, and levels of professional support – and consumers can now choose between over-the-counter and prescription hearing aids.

The right choice depends on more than the appearance or price of the device. Your degree of hearing loss, lifestyle, comfort, dexterity, and need fro professional support should all be considered.

This article explains the difference between over-the-counter and prescription hearing aids and outlines five important factors to consider before making a purchase.

Important: This article provides general educational information and is not a substitute for advice from a physician, audiologist, or other qualified hearing professional.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

What is the Difference Between Over-the-Counter and Prescription Hearing Aids?

Both over-the-Counter and prescription hearing aids are medical devices designed to improve hearing. However, they are intended for different people and are purchased in different ways.

Over-the-Counter Hearing Aids

Over-the-counter, or OTC, hearing aids are intended for adults age 18 and older who believe they have mild to moderate hearing loss.

They can be purchased online or in stores without:

  • A prescription
  • A medical examination
  • A hearing test
  • An appointment with an audiologist

The FDA established the OTC hearing-aid category to make hearing assistance more accessible and affordable. Although a professional evaluation is not required, the National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders explains why understanding your degree of hearing loss can help you decide whether an OTC hearing aid is appropriate for your hearing loss.

Some OTC hearing aids arrive with preset listening programs. Others allow you to personalize the settings using a smartphone app, an online hearing test, or controls on the device.

Prescription Hearing Aids

Prescription hearing aids are fitted and programmed with the assistance of a hearing professional, such as an audiologist or licensed hearing-aid specialist.

They may be a better choice for people who:

  • Have severe or profound hearing loss
  • Are younger than 18
  • Have a complicated hearing condition
  • Need a custom earmold
  • have significantly different hearing levels in each ear
  • Need help selecting, fitting, or adjusting their devices
  • Prefer ongoing professional support

A professional hearing evaluation can also identify hearing problems that may require medical attention rather than amplification alone.

OTC and Prescription Hearing Aids at a Glance

Over-the-Counter Hearing Aids

  • For adults age 18 and older
  • intended for perceived mild to moderate hearing loss
  • no prescription or professional hearing test required
  • Usually adjusted by the user or through a smartphone app
  • Often less expensive 
  • Customer service and follow-up support vary by company

Prescription Hearing Aids

  • Available for people of all ages
  • Appropriate for mild through profound hearing loss
  • Selected using a professional hearing evaluation
  • Fitted and programmed for our individual hearing needs
  • Generally more expensive
  • Usually include professional fitting and follow-up support

Older woman wearing a hearing aid while talking with her husband

Top 5 Things to Consider When Choosing a Hearing Aid

1.Is an OTC Hearing Aid Appropriate for Your Hearing Loss?

OTC hearing aids are not designed for every type of hearing loss.

Mild to moderate hearing loss may cause you to:

  • Ask people to repeat themselves
  • Turn up the television more than others prefer
  • Have difficulty following conversations in groups
  • Struggle to understand speech when background noise is present
  • Feel that people frequently mumble

If you regularly cannot hear conversations even in a quiet room, an OTC device may not provide enough assistance. A professional hearing test is the best way to determine how much hearing loss you have and which frequencies are affected.

Hearing loss can also be caused or worsened by earwax, infection, medication, injury, or another medical condition. A hearing aid makes sounds more audible, but it does not treat the underlying cause of hearing loss.

2.Where Do You Have the Most Difficulty Hearing?

Think about the situations in which better hearing would make the greatest difference in your daily life.

For example:

  • Do you have difficulty hearing the television?
  • Do you struggle to follow conversations in restaurants?
  • Do you attend church services, lectures, or community events?
  • Do you frequently talk on the telephone?
  • Do you spend time outdoors where wind noise is a concern?
  • Do you want to stream calls, music, or television audio through the hearing aids?

Someone who primarily wants help hearing television at home may need different technology than someone who frequently participates in meetings, restaurants, or large family gatherings.

If television is your biggest listening challenge, you may also want to explore a wireless TV speaker. or wireless TV headphones.

Make a list of your three most challenging listening situations. Use that list when comparing devices or speaking with a hearing professional.

3.Which Hearing-Aid Style Will Be Easiest to Use?

Hearing aids come in several styles. Smaller is not always better – especially if you have limited vision, arthritis, numbness, or difficulty handling small objects.

Older woman shopping online and comparing hearing-aid options

Behind-the-Ear Hearing Aids

A behind-the-ear, or BTE, hearing aid rests behind the ear and connects to an earpiece inside the ear.

These devices are often:

  • Easier to handle
  • Available with rechargable batteries
  • capable of providing more amplification
  • Suitable for a wide range of hearing loss

However, they are generally more visible than devices worn inside the ear.

Receiver-in-Canal Hearing Aids

Receiver-in-canal, or RIC, devices have a small component behind the ear connected by a thin wire to a receiver in the ear canal.

They are popular because they are relatively discreet, comfortable, and available with many advanced features. The receiver and wax guard may require regular cleaning or replacement.

In-the-Ear and In-the-Canal Hearing Aids

These devices fit partially or completely inside the ear.

They may be less noticeable, but their smaller controls and batteries can be difficult to manage. They may also be more vulnerable to moisture and earwax.

Before buying, consider whether you can comfortably insert, remove, clean, charge, and adjust the hearing aids. A device cannot improve your hearing if it is too frustrating to use consistently.

4.Which Features Are Worth Paying For?

Modern hearing aids may offer an impressive list of features, but not every feature is necessary for every person.

Useful features may include:

  • Rechargable batteries: Helpful for people who do not want to replace very small batteries.
  • Directional microphones: Help the device focus on sounds coming from in front of you.
  • Noise reduction: May make listening in busy environments more comfortable, although it cannot eliminate all background noise.
  • Feedback management: Helps reduce squealing or whistling.
  • Bluetooth connectivity: Allows compatible hearing aids to stream telephone calls, music, or television audio.
  • Telecoil capability: Connects with compatible telephones and hearing-loop systems found in some theaters, churches, and public buildings.
  • Multiple listening programs: Allows different settings for quiet rooms, restaurants, outdoor environments, or music.
  • Smartphone controls: Let you adjust volume and other settings through an app.
  • Remote professional support: Some companies offer online assistance with setup and adjustments.

Choose features based on the activities that matter to you – not simply because a device is advertised as having the newest technolgy.

5.What Support, Return Policy, and Warranty Are Included?

Adjustment is an important part of successfully using a hearing aid. Even a well-selected device may initially make your own voice, dishes, paper, or other everyday sounds seem unusually loud.

Before purchasing an OTC hearing aid, find out:

  • How long you have to return it
  • Whether the return period begins when you order or receive it
  • Whether return shipping or restocking fees apply
  • How the device is adjusted
  • Whether telephone or online assistance is available
  • How long the warranty lasts
  • whether loss or accidental damage is covered
  • How repairs are handled
  • Whether replacement parts are readily available

When considering a prescription hearing aid, ask whether the quoted price includes the hearing evaluation, fitting appointments, follow-up adjustments, cleaning, repairs, and future service.

The lowest initial price does not always provide the best overall value. Support can be especially important during the first several weeks.

When Should You See a Doctor or Hearing Professional First?

Do not rely solely on an OTC hearing aid if you have symptoms that could indicate a medical problem.

Seek medical or professional guidance if you experience:

  • Sudden hearing loss or hearing that worsens quickly
  • Hearing loss primarily in one ear
  • Ear pain
  • Fluid, blood, or puss draining from an ear
  • Significant dizziness or balance problems
  • A feeling that something is blocking the ear
  • Excessive earwax that you cannot safely remove
  • A noticeable difference between the hearing in your two ears
  • Ringing that occurs mainly in one ear
  • Hearing difficulty that interferes significantly with everyday conversation

Sudden hearing loss can require prompt treatment. contact a healthcare professional without waiting to see whether a hearing aid solves the problem.

Anyone younger than 18 should be evaluated by a qualified healthcare professional and should not use an OTC hearing aid unless directed by that professional.

Hearing Aids Are Not the Same as Personal Sound Amplification Products

Be careful not to confuse hearing aids with personal sound amplification products, sometimes called PSAPs or sound amplifiers.

Hearing aids are medical devices intended to compensate for hearing loss. Personal sound amplifiers are consumer products intended to make sounds louder for people with normal hearing during activities such as bird-watching or listening to a distant speaker.

A product advertised simply as a “hearing amplifier” may not meet the FDA requirements for an OTC hearing aid. Look for clear labeling that identifies the product as an OTC hearing aid.

Should You Start With an OTC or Prescription Hearing Aid?

An OTC hearing aid may be a reasonable place to start if you:

  • Are at least 18 years old
  • Believe your hearing loss is mild to moderate
  • Do not have concerning ear symptoms
  • Feel comfortable setting up and adjusting technology
  • Want a lower-cost way to explore hearing assistance
  • Understand the return policy and available support

A prescription hearing aid may be the better choice if you:

  • Have more significant or complicated hearing loss
  • Want a complete professional hearing evaluation
  • Need custom fit 
  • Have difficulty using small devices or smartphone apps
  • Have tried an OTC device without success
  • Want in-person adjustments and continuing support

Even if you are interested in an OTC hearing aid, you can still schedule a hearing test first. Knowing what type of hearing loss you have can make you a much more informed shopper.

The Bottom Line

The best hearing aid is not necessarily the smallest, most expensive, or most technologically advanced option. It is the one that fits your hearing needs, lifestyle, comfort level, and budget – and that you will wear consistently.

Over-the counter hearing aids have made hearing assistance avaialble to more adults, particularly those with mild to moderate hearing loss. Prescription hearing aids continue to offer important benefits for people who need customized programming, professional fitting, or treatment for more complex hearing needs.

Whichever route you choose, check the return policy, allow yourself time to adjust, and aks for help if the device is uncomfortable or does not provide the improvement you expected. better hearing can make conversations, activities, and everyday life more enjoyable – and taking the first step is worth it.

Your Next Step Toward Aging Well

Aging well is about more than staying healthy. It’s about feeling confident, staying independent, and making thoughtful choices for the future.

Our FREE Aging Well Guide offers practical tips for home safety, healthy and active living, and planning ahead—so you can take meaningful steps toward living well at every age.

Get Your Free Aging Well Guide →

Practical guidance to help you live well and age with purpose.

About the Author

I’m Heather, founder of Age With Intent. I have more than 25 years of experience in long-term care leadership, including over 15 years as a Nursing Home Administrator.

Throughout my career, I’ve seen firsthand how important safety, independence, and thoughtful planning are to aging well.

I created Age With Intent to share practical information and resources that help older adults and their families make informed decisions, maintain independence, and live well at every stage of life.

Don't Miss Helpful Tips for Aging Well at Home

Get your free guide with simple ideas for safety, comfort, and healthy living.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *